Elora Hayward

Elora Hayward's signature, 1869 (SCSU Archives)

Josiah Hayward, 1880-1889 (Ancestry.com)

Mary Hayward, 1900-1910 (Ancestry.com)

Paul Martin Holden, 1930-1938 (Ancestry.com)

Hayward plot marker, North Star Cemetery, St. Cloud, Minnesota (Find A Grave)

Elora H. Holden headstone, North Star Cemetery, St. Cloud, Minnesota (Find A Grave)

Elora E. Hayward was born in Maine on February 2, 1852 to Josiah Eaton and Mary Stinson (Gray) Hayward and was the fourth of their eight children. Her father was an influential farmer and businessman. Josiah was born in Mechanics’ Falls, Maine on February 2, 1826. After he and Mary were married in 1848, he and his brother, Samuel, came to Minnesota in 1849, but returned back east. Josiah, Mary, and their children came to Minnesota to stay in 1856. Initially settling in what became Brockway township in Stearns County, Minnesota, Josiah and Mary began their fortune in the pine industry along the upper Mississippi. Josiah was elected chairman of Brockway's first board of supervisors. The family moved to St. Cloud in 1860, where on April 13, 1863, Josiah purchased the Central House, rebuilding it in brick and renaming it the Grand Central Hotel. He also purchased the West Hotel, was director of the German American and Merchants’ National Banks, and built a farm and mill near the city. During the 1880s and 1890s, his two hotels were the only St. Cloud businesses to hire African Americans, including John Wesley Webster, the father of St. Cloud State's first documented African-American student, Ruby Cora Webster.

Elora entered the Third State Normal School with her sister, Clara, in September 1869. Clara dropped out, but Elora graduated with the school’s first class on June 30, 1871. In her culminating essay, “Music as an Educator,” she argued that the refinement of “civilized nations” was in part due to the refinement of their music. As of 1873, Elora had not yet found a teaching position. She continued to live at home until 1883, when she married Dr. Emmet Clark Holden, a dentist from Vermont. One year earlier, Emmet had settled in St. Cloud and bought out Dr. Edward K. Jaques’s practice. Their daughter, Genevieve H., was born on February 22, 1884.

Around 1891, the couple moved to St. Paul, where Emmet became one of the city's leading dentists. Genevieve passed away on November 4, 1897 at only 12 years old, and Elora and Emmet never had another child. After Emmet’s passing on August 3, 1907, Elora lived on income from investments they had accrued. Moving to Chicago around 1909 with a secretary and two servants from Minnesota, she lived in one of the city’s wealthier neighborhoods, where she supplemented her income by taking in a boarder.

After her mother’s passing on September 1, 1912, Elora moved back to St. Cloud, where she lived on Third Avenue South and hired a maid and a chauffeur, Paul Martin Truzinski, a World War I veteran whose first language was Polish. Although he was in his twenties and his mother was still alive, Elora adopted Paul in the early 1920s. He took Holden as his last name. Elora passed away on September 2, 1926 in Collegeville, Minnesota. She, Emmet, and Genevieve are buried in St. Cloud’s North Star Cemetery. Paul was one of only three beneficiaries of her estate. Going by Paul M. Holden, he used his inheritance to move to Minneapolis and purchase ownership of copper and iron mines in the state. He died at age 44 on April 24, 1938 after moving to Seattle, where he is buried in Calvary Cemetery.

Sources

1860 U.S. census, Stearns County, Minnesota, population schedule, Brockway, p. 866, dwelling 300, family 233; NARA microfilm publication M653, roll 574, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1870 U.S. census, Stearns County, Minnesota, population schedule, St. Cloud Ward 3, p. 144B, dwelling 66, family 66; NARA microfilm publication T132, roll 716, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1875 Minnesota census, Stearns County, St. Cloud, p. 188, family 221; Minnesota Historical Society microfilm publication MNSC_16, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1895 Minnesota census, Ramsey County, St. Paul Ward 7, p. 33, n.f.; Minnesota Historical Society microfilm publication V290_87, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1900 U.S. census, Ramsey County, Minnesota, population schedule, St. Paul Ward 4, enumeration district 0088, p. 12, dwelling 77, family 238; NARA microfilm publication T623, n.r., accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1910 U.S. census, Cook County, Illinois, population schedule, Chicago Ward 7, enumeration district 0392, p. 6B, dwelling 45, family 102; NARA microfilm publication T624, roll 247, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1910 U.S. census, Stearns County, Minnesota, population schedule, St. Cloud Ward 4, enumeration district 0158, p. 11A, dwelling 181, family 194; NARA microfilm publication T624, roll 727, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1920 U.S. census, Stearns County, Minnesota, population schedule, St. Cloud Ward 2, enumeration district 208, p. 12B, dwelling 199, family 256; NARA microfilm publication T625, roll 863, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1920 U.S. census, Stearns County, Minnesota, population schedule, St. Cloud Ward 2, enumeration district 208, p. 8A, dwelling 119, family 175; NARA microfilm publication T625, roll 863, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

1930 U.S. census, Hennepin County, Minnesota, population schedule, Minneapolis, enumeration district 0142, p. 5A, dwelling 39, family 76; NARA microfilm publication T626, n.r., accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

Christopher P. Lehman,“Black Cloud: The Struggles of St. Cloud's African American Community, 1880-1920,” Minnesota History 66, no. 6 (Summer 2019): 235-236.

Elora H. Holden, last will and testament, Will Record: Stearns County Probate Court, vol. 1: 1922-1925, p. 358-360, accessed July 19, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

Memorial page for Charles Truzinski (1860–17 Sep 1908), Find A Grave Memorial no. 158949744, citing Calvary Cemetery, Saint Cloud, Stearns County, Minnesota, USA; maintained by St. Cloud Area Geni (contributor 48774097); accessed July 19, 2019.

Memorial page for Dr. Emmet Clark Holden (25 Aug 1849–8 Aug 1907), Find A Grave Memorial no. 97551495, citing North Star Cemetery, Saint Cloud, Stearns County, Minnesota, USA; maintained by kandota (contributor 47586653); accessed July 19, 2019.

Memorial page for Elora H. Hayward Holden (2 Feb 1852–2 Sep 1926), Find A Grave Memorial no. 97551220, citing North Star Cemetery, Saint Cloud, Stearns County, Minnesota, USA; maintained by kandota (contributor 47586653); accessed July 19, 2019.

Memorial page for Genevieve H. Holden (22 Feb 1885–4 Nov 1897), Find A Grave Memorial no. 97551926, citing North Star Cemetery, Saint Cloud, Stearns County, Minnesota, USA; maintained by kandota (contributor 47586653); accessed July 19, 2019.

Memorial page for Mary Harry Truzinski (1868–7 Feb 1933), Find A Grave Memorial no. 158949745, citing Calvary Cemetery, Saint Cloud, Stearns County, Minnesota, USA; maintained by St. Cloud Area Geni (contributor 48774097); accessed July 19, 2019.

Memorial page for Paul Martin Truzinski Holden (14 Jan 1894–24 Apr 1938), Find A Grave Memorial no. 62800116, citing Calvary Cemetery, Seattle, King County, Washington, USA; maintained by Pat (contributor 47394437); accessed July 19, 2019.

Minnesota Department of Health, Elora Holden death record, 1926, Minnesota Death Index, 1908-2017, accessed July 19, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

“Normal School Examination: Exercises of the Graduating Class,” The St. Cloud Journal, July 6, 1871, http://www.mnhs.org/newspapers/hub (accessed July 16, 2019).

“Opening of the Normal School,” The St. Cloud Journal, September 23, 1869, http://www.mnhs.org/newspapers/hub (accessed July 16, 2019).

Paul Martin Holden portrait, ca. 1930, photograph, uploaded July 13, 2013 to Ancestry.com by bsheridan9, https://www.ancestry.com/mediaui-viewer/tree/72106864/person/142024948138/media/d5a3c0e5-1e9c-431e-9844-0638f94d37a4.

State Normal School at St. Cloud, “Catalogue and Circular of the State Normal School at St. Cloud, Minnesota,” 1884-1885, p. 5, series 1, box 1, folder 1, St. Cloud State University Undergraduate Catalogs, 1869-2012+, St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections.

State Normal School at St. Cloud, “Alumni Directory of the State Normal School,” 1908, p. 1, series 6, box 10, folder 1, Records of the St. Cloud State Alumni Association, 1874-2006, St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections.

State Normal School at St. Cloud, “Record Book” 1869-1885, box 1, folder 1, Admission and Records Records, 1869-1939, St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections.

St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections, transcript index, https://www.stcloudstate.edu/library/archives/histories/transcript-index.aspx (accessed July 16, 2019).

St. Paul, Minnesota City Directory, 1908, p. 827, U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

St. Paul, Minnesota City Directory, 1909, p. 861, U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995, accessed July 20, 2019 on Ancestry.com.

Third State Normal School, undergraduate commencement program, 1871, series 1, box 1, folder 1, Records of St. Cloud State University Commencement, 1871-2018+, St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections.

United States Selective Service System, Paul Martin Truszinski draft registration card, 1917, Stearns County, Minnesota, draft board 1, card number 41, World War I Selective Service System Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918, National Archives and Records Administration publication M1509.

William Bell Mitchell, History of Stearns County, Minnesota, vol. 1 (Chicago: H. C. Cooper, Jr. & Co., 1915), 83-85, 402.

Works Progress Administration, “Josiah E. Hayward Biography,” 1937, box 3, folder 8, WPA Stearns County Biographies, 1936-1939, St. Cloud State University Archives and Special Collections.